Jamaica Plain, June 16, 2002, Rev. Terry Burke
In the past I have preached on the "Mothers of the Church," women like Susanna Pemberton,
who convinced her husband to help build a church on the Jamaica Plain, Helen Holmes, the
"guardian angel of the church," Elfie Barnard, now in her 98th year, the honorary church
grandmother, and Ellen Morse, whose portrait hangs in the nursery, and who taught church school for
over 70 years.
For Fathers' Day, my wife Ellen McGuire suggested that I speak on some of the historic
"Fathers of the Church." These fathers have helped preserve the institution, and have helped serve
as keepers of the tradition, something like keepers of the lore in a tribal society.
The text from Matthew today is one of the Lectionary readings for this Sunday. Saying that the
"harvest is plentiful, but the laborers are few," Jesus gives authority to the original 12 disciples.
This varied bunch includes the tax collector Matthew, a former collaborator with the Roman overlords,
and the former revolutionary Simon the Zealot, and of course, Judas.
Today, in talking about the fathers of our church, I want to speak especially about our lay
leaders; in the past I have focused on our clergy types. I earlier mentioned Susannah Pemberton.
Her wealthy merchant husband helped in the negotiations that led to the creation of our congregation.
He promised to continue paying his pledge to the 2nd church in Roxbury (now the Theodore Parker Church
in West Roxbury) as well as pledging to our new church in J.P. Legend has it that he became angry
with our first minister, Dr. Gordon, when the cleric tied his horse to Pemberton's wet fence.
In any case, he left his large estate for the welfare of the widows and orphans of Boston, and is
remembered by Pemberton Square downtown.
I met Clifford Bond at the end of his long life; he died in his mid 90's. He had worked for the
Boston Chamber of Commerce, and on a business trip to New York City he met a women who struck him as
"the one." He invited her to dinner at Delmonico's restaurant, then didn't contact her again until
the next time he was in New York, six weeks later. During a second dinner at Delmonico's, he proposed
marriage. She said "No," arguing that they barely knew each other. Returning to Boston,
Bond wrote a Machiavellian note that, "Of course you are right in turning me down. It wouldn't
have worked out." His future bride wrote back, "Let's not be too hasty," and they were wed for over
50 years. Mr. Bond had what was described as a "loping style" as he went down the aisle to help
take the collection. He enjoyed inviting our music director Ellen McGuire and our then soloist
Susan Brodie over to his home for homemade popovers before church. Ellen and Susan would worry
that they would be late for the service as he slowly prepared the popovers, but he always finished
in time. Mr. Bond was also a great keeper of records, serving as our church clerk for 54 years.
Last week we awarded Thalia McMillion the Ellsworth Winchester Award for church leadership.
Ellsworth was proud of his family's long connection to this church; Winchesters are buried in our
graveyard going back to the 18th century. This is a photo of Ellsworth's church school class.
He would tell me stories of an earlier Jamaica Plain, where he and his siblings would take turns bathing
in a tub of heated water in the middle of the kitchen floor. It saddened him that the name of the street
where he grew up was changed from Winchester to Westchester Street. Ellsworth married a Catholic woman,
Estelle, and everyone said it wouldn't last. When in her 80's, Estelle told me how they'd courted by
going out riding in the early morning hours in J.P. During World War Two, Ellsworth served as an
officer in the military, traveling around the country trying to convince workers not to go on strike.
In the work world, he was known as "Fred." When the church was at a low point in the 1970's,
his brother Artemas, the standing committee chair, asked Ellsworth to join the committee.
A few months later, Artemas died of a heart attack, and Ellsworth became chairperson of the
standing committee, and later head of our new trustees, who were set up to safeguard our endowment.
Ellsworth kept a close eye on our church building. He told me once, "The most important thing is
to keep the roof tight." He felt that our relationship with the 1st and 2nd Church downtown had
saved the church, and he was reluctance to sever that relationship for new experiments.
He was a fiscal conservative, a stay agent who was not convinced for a long time that the church could
revive. Yet as head usher, he would grab newcomers by the elbow and tell them the history of "his"
church. He had a wonderful institutional memory, and eventually delighted in the revival of the
congregation.
Stannard Bristol also grew up in our church. His father was a prominent obstetrician; Elfie
Barnard was his nurse. Dr. Bristol took his young son with him for a delivery which turned out to be a
C-section; Stannard never had any interest in following his father's career. His family moved
upcountry to North Sutton, New Hampshire when Stannard was going away to college. Stannard later
restored their historic home, worked as a land surveyor, and ran the town of Sutton as head selectperson.
(I once had the delightful experience of "perambulating" or walking the town boundary between Sutton
and Warner with Stannard and what he described as "colorful Warner types").
Acquiring many historic buildings, he had his Muster Field Farm worked as a traditional farm.
Stannard (known upcountry as "Bob") created the tradition of Farm Days, a celebration of traditional
rural crafts at the Muster Field Farm, now an incorporated museum. I have fond memories of attending
Farm Days; when the day ended, thousands of people would leave, and Stannard and Ellen and I would
fix dinner.
Stannard loved tradition, but he was willing to experiment with change. He remained fiercely
devoted to our church as a result of a transformative confirmation class that he had with our minister,
Dr. Frank Holmes. In the late 1970's, he served as our standing committee chairperson, riding the bus
100 miles each way on Sunday morning from North Sutton. Stannard proposed that the church experiment
by cutting its ties with First and Second and hiring its own minister. He was a strong supporter of my
ministry to revive the church. I remember walking on Eliot Street with him just before my first
Easter Sunday service in 1983. A seagull swooped down and pooped on my new suit. "That's good luck,"
said Stannard.
Soon after I arrived at the church, Stannard revived a custom he remembered from his childhood,
having undecorated trees in the front of the church for Christmas. He'd cut the trees in his woods
and haul them down to J.P. He once told our church school that it was important that they were wild,
natural trees, and hadn't been cultivated and shaped.
In our lesson from Wendell Berry's The Memory of Old Jack, Mat Feltner exercises his prerogative as
an old man at Jack Beecham's graveside service, and turns his back on a garrulous young preacher.
This story reminds me of Stannard Bristol, someone I think of as giving me "old guy lessons" before
his untimely death in his early seventies from diabetes. Ellen and I were honored that
Stannard visited us for two days in Maine for the only vacation anyone could ever remember that
he had taken. He said that he wanted to see where his friends Frank and Helen Holmes had vacationed.
While staying with us in Maine, Stannard expressed an interest in seeing a local 18th century building,
the Parson Fisher House, now a museum. "I guess I'll get dressed for town," he said. He emerged from
his room a few minutes later, dressed in jeans and a clean white "T" shirt.
His friend Dr. Frank Holmes, who had been our minister from 1927-42, retired with his wife Helen to
JP in the early 70's just as the diminished congregation considered merging with the Brookline UU
church. Instead, Frank arranged with his friend Dr. Rhys Williams for First Church to be a preaching
station for student ministers serving the First and Second Church downtown. Frank had a strong sense
of worship and the importance of music in the liturgy. He gave good advice to the students,
who included now noted preacher Forester Church.
Frank Holmes also had a strong sense of justice. He was active in organizations such as the
American Civil Liberties Union and Urban League, which was putting his beliefs on the line in pastorates
like Oklahoma City in the 1940's. He once held a community meeting in Oklahoma City to denounce the
evils of McCarthyism. A non-church member rose and said to Holmes, "You're nothing but a commie dupe!"
To which Frank Holmes responded, "You can call me a communist, but don't call me a dupe!"
We give thanks today for Mr. Pemberton, a founder and generous benefactor; for Cliff Bond, a keeper
of the records; for Ellsworth Winchester, conservative stay agent, who cared for this building;
for Stannard Bristol, creative traditionalist and change agent; and for Frank Holmes, forging our
traditions of worship and music and social justice. As we go through a time of congregational growth
and transition, we give thanks for the caring and keeping of tradition of these church fathers.
We give thanks that they have helped give to us this gift of community.